MLPs in an Irrevocable Trust: When the Tax Shelter Becomes the Tax Problem

Irrevocable trusts plus MLPs: 37% trust tax at $15,200 of income, UBTI on Form 990-T, and possibly no §1014 step-up. Computed side-by-side with direct ownership — with the rescue paths for positions already trapped.

By Lucas Andersen — Masters in Finance, proprietary energy trader, direct MLP holder

Last updated:

This article is for educational purposes. Trust law varies significantly by state, and the interaction between trust structures and partnership taxation is complex. Consult a qualified CPA and estate planning attorney before making decisions about MLPs in trust structures.

Key Takeaways

  • Irrevocable trusts hit the top 37% federal bracket at $15,200 of income — individuals don’t reach that rate until $731,200 (MFJ). MLP K-1 income inside a trust is taxed at these compressed rates under §1(e).
  • MLP income inside irrevocable trusts can generate UBTI under §512, triggering Form 990-T filing, additional CPA costs, and tax at compressed trust rates. §751 recapture at sale is also UBTI.
  • IDGTs may NOT receive §1014 step-up at death — meaning all accumulated basis erosion and §751 recapture survive, passing to beneficiaries unreset. For estates under the $13.61M exemption, the IDGT saves $0 in estate tax but costs the full step-up.
  • The §675(4) swap power is the one-phone-call fix. Most IDGT documents include it. Swap MLPs OUT of the trust into your taxable account, swap Treasuries or cash IN. Step-up restored, estate tax plan preserved.
  • Options exist for MLPs already trapped: §663(b) 65-day distributions, §675(4) swap power, trust decanting, in-kind distribution, court-ordered modification, or selective liquidation.

37% at $15,200: Why Trust Tax Brackets Punish MLP Income

Irrevocable trusts use compressed federal brackets under IRC §1(e). The top 37% rate hits at $15,200. An MFJ couple doesn’t reach 37% until $731,200 — roughly 48x higher. 2024 trust brackets: 10% to $3,100 · 24% to $11,150 · 35% to $15,200 · 37% above. For a trust with $30,000 of taxable income, the trust tax is approximately $9,135 (30.5% effective) versus roughly $7,200 at individual 24% — $1,935/year of compression cost, $19,350 over a decade. Compression becomes a real drag once aggregate trust income climbs above $15,200.

The Same Portfolio, Two Trust Types

Revocable trust during grantor’s life: individual rates, no UBTI, no 990-T, full §199A QBI, full §1014 step-up at death. Irrevocable non-grantor trust: compressed trust rates, UBTI above $1,000, 990-T required, limited QBI, step-up DEPENDS on trust type. For the canonical 5-MLP Y15 portfolio ($164,770 FMV), the revocable structure eliminates ~$39,406 in federal tax and ~$84,000 in §751 recapture at death. The irrevocable non-grantor trust may eliminate none of it. For estates under the $13.61M exemption, the irrevocable trust provides $0 in estate tax savings on the MLP portion.

The IDGT Trap: When Step-Up Disappears

An Intentionally Defective Grantor Trust is designed to be defective for income tax (grantor pays tax on trust income) but effective for estate tax (assets outside the gross estate). For stocks, this is a good deal — 40% estate tax saved outweighs 15-20% LTCG paid later. For MLPs, it fails: because IDGT assets are outside the estate, they may NOT receive §1014 step-up. All accumulated basis erosion survives. All §751 ordinary-income recapture survives. The deferred tax liability §1014 would have eliminated passes to beneficiaries unreset. For a long-held midstream MLP position at basis ~0, the step-up cost is roughly 24% of FMV. For estates under $13.61M, the IDGT provides zero estate tax savings on MLPs while costing the full step-up — pure loss.

The Phone Call That Fixes Everything: §675(4) Swap Power

Most IDGTs include a §675(4) substitution power allowing the grantor to swap assets of equivalent value in and out of the trust. For MLPs trapped in an IDGT, this is the escape hatch. Swap EPD units OUT of the IDGT into your taxable account; swap Treasury bonds of equal value INTO the IDGT. Trust value unchanged. Estate tax planning preserved. MLPs now in taxable account → §1014 step-up restored at death. One transaction, one phone call. For a long-held midstream MLP position, step-up value restored is ~24% of FMV: ~$40,000 on a $164,770 portfolio, ~$120,000 on a $500K portfolio. Phone script for the attorney: “I’d like to exercise the swap power under §675(4). I want to swap [MLP units] out of the trust and replace them with [Treasuries] of equal value. Can you confirm the trust document includes the provision and coordinate with the trustee?”

16-Year IDGT Autopsy

John and Mary set up an IDGT in 2010. Transferred 2,000 EPD units at $25/unit. For 16 years, annual tax was IDENTICAL to direct ownership (grantor trust → income on John’s personal return). By 2025, basis had eroded to ~$0, §751 accumulated to ~$44,000. John dies in 2026. Divergence: in a taxable account, §1014 step-up resets basis to $75,000 FMV, eliminates §751, child sells at ~$0 tax. In the IDGT, no step-up: basis stays $0, §751 survives. Child sells at $75,000: $31,000 LTCG at 18.8% = $5,828 + $44,000 §751 at 32% = $14,080, total ~$20,908 federal tax. Estate tax saved (estate under $13.61M exemption): $0. Net cost of the IDGT structure on this position: $20,908 wasted.

The §751 UBTI Time Bomb

When a non-grantor irrevocable trust sells MLP units, accumulated §751 recapture — ordinary-income-in-disguise from years of depreciation — is realized all at once as UBTI under §512. At trust-compressed rates. In a single year. On Form 990-T. For 2,000 EPD units held 15 years: ~$60,000 of accumulated §751, roughly $21,500 in federal tax at trust rates (after the $1,000 §512(b)(12) exemption), plus $500-1,500 in 990-T CPA prep. The same position held directly and inherited at step-up would owe $0. This is the UBTI problem most advisors warn about for IRAs — identical mechanics, just in a trust instead of an IRA, and almost nobody flags it.

Bypass Trusts and Dynasty Trusts

Pre-2012 bypass / credit shelter trusts were standard estate planning — use both spouses’ exemptions via an irrevocable B trust at first death. Since 2012 portability, they’re often unnecessary. MLPs stuck in these trusts bleed basis at compressed rates. Options: §663(b) 65-day distributions, in-kind distribution, selective liquidation, decanting (~40 states allow), court modification. Dynasty trusts face a worse problem: perpetual compression with no §1014 reset mechanism, because the trust doesn’t die. Over 100 years, a $500K MLP portfolio in a dynasty trust costs approximately $460,000 more in cumulative tax than direct ownership with generational step-ups. Dynasty trusts work for growth stocks. They work poorly for MLPs.

Rescue Playbook

If in an IDGT: check for §675(4) swap power first — swap MLPs out today. If no swap power, evaluate decanting or modification. If in bypass trust: use §663(b) annually, consider in-kind distribution, consider selective liquidation. If in dynasty trust: use §663(b) aggressively, liquidate complex MLPs first (ET: 3 K-1s, 40+ states), quantify ongoing cost. If planning a new irrevocable trust: don’t put MLPs in. Hold them directly in a taxable account or grantor trust that will be included in the gross estate. Transfer stocks and real estate into the irrevocable trust; keep MLPs out.

State Trust Income Tax

No trust income tax: Delaware, Nevada, South Dakota, Alaska, Wyoming, Florida, Texas, Washington. Highest rates: California 13.3% (trustee, beneficiary, OR administration triggers nexus), New York 10.9%, New Jersey 10.75%. For a trust in California holding MLPs, combined federal trust rates plus state approach a 50% effective rate. Changing trust situs to a no-income-tax state can eliminate the state layer — requires appointing a trustee in the new state and meeting nexus rules. Consult an attorney.