PAA 20-Year Tax Projection

500 units of Plains All American Pipeline at $20/unit — IRS Partner’s Basis Worksheet methodology with full citations.

This tool provides projections based on assumptions. It does not constitute tax, legal, or investment advice. Consult a qualified CPA or financial advisor before making decisions based on this output.

Assumptions for this projection:

  • Position: 500 units at $20 per unit ($10,000 total)
  • Distribution: $0.42/quarter ($1.67/year), growing at 8.0%
  • Growth source: 5yr CAGR inflated by recovery from 50% cut in 2020. 10yr CAGR is NEGATIVE — current distribution still well below 2016 level ($2.80/yr). Distribution increasing ~$0.10-0.15/year.
  • ROC: ~80% of distribution (estimated from historical K-1 data)
  • Federal tax bracket: 32% (Married Filing Jointly)
  • NIIT: 3.8% on investment income above $250,000 threshold
  • §199A QBI deduction: active (20% on qualified PTP income)
  • K-1 entities: 1
  • Operating states: ~18

These are default assumptions based on historical data. For your actual numbers → Enter your position in the Portfolio Simulator

Last computed: 2026-11-05 | Engine: 429 tests passing | v0.1.0

Your broker says

Cost Basis: $10,000

Gain if sold: $9,898

Tax owed: $1,861

Projected adjusted basis

Adjusted Basis: $0.00

Actual gain: $19,898

Actual tax: $5,876

Net investment income tax (3.8%, R-1411-RATE-THRESHOLD): a capital loss on the units offsets the §751 amount this year only up to the §1211(b) amount ($3,000, or $1,500 if married filing separately) (Reg. §1.1411-4(d)(2)); any part over that amount is a §1212(b) carryover, which this estimate does not model. The estimate treats the §751 amount as net investment income for a holder for whom the units were a passive activity in every year held (R-1411-NET-GAIN-CAPITAL-LOSS, condition 1); no source states this for a sale. This assumes no other capital gains or losses and no other net investment income; other items change the amount.

⚠ BROKER UNDERSTATES YOUR TAX BY $4,015

Zero-Basis Year

Year 11

20-Year Cash Collected

$38,215

20-Year Federal Tax

$6,113

Effective Tax Rate

16.0%

§751 Recapture (est.)

~$20,000

Estimated — actual determined by MLP sales schedule

Successor’s Basis at Death (§1014(a); projected value, before the liability-share and IRD adjustments)

$19,898

R-1014-PTP-STEP-UP; the successor’s tax is not computed

Basis Erosion — PAA Over 20 Years

Blue line: base case (8.0% growth). Shaded area: sensitivity range. Yellow marker: basis reaches zero in Year 11.

PAA IRS Adjusted Basis Over 20 Years $0.00 $2,625 $5,250 $7,875 $10,500 1 5 10 15 20 IRS Basis ($) Year Year 11

Cumulative Cash vs. Tax — PAA

The growing gap between distributions received and taxes paid is the core value proposition of MLP holding.

PAA Cumulative Cash Collected vs Tax Paid Over 20 Years $0.00 $10,509 $21,018 $31,527 $42,037 1 5 10 15 20 Year $38,215 $6,113 Distributions Received Cumulative Tax Paid

PAA 20-Year Projection Table

Year Distribution K-1 Taxable §731 Gain Federal Tax Ending Basis Cum. Cash Eff. Rate
1 $835 $167 — $49 $9,332 $835 5.9%
2 $902 $180 — $53 $8,611 $1,737 5.9%
3 $974 $195 — $57 $7,832 $2,711 5.9%
4 $1,052 $210 — $62 $6,991 $3,763 5.9%
5 $1,136 $227 — $67 $6,082 $4,899 5.9%
6 $1,227 $245 — $72 $5,100 $6,126 5.9%
7 $1,325 $265 — $78 $4,040 $7,451 5.9%
8 $1,431 $286 — $84 $2,895 $8,882 5.9%
9 $1,546 $309 — $91 $1,659 $10,428 5.9%
10 $1,669 $334 — $98 $324 $12,097 5.9%
11 $1,803 $361 $1,118 $316 $0.00 $13,900 7.4%
12 $1,947 $389 $1,558 $407 $0.00 $15,847 9.0%
13 $2,103 $421 $1,682 $440 $0.00 $17,950 10.4%
14 $2,271 $454 $1,817 $475 $0.00 $20,221 11.6%
15 $2,453 $491 $1,962 $513 $0.00 $22,674 12.6%
16 $2,649 $530 $2,119 $554 $0.00 $25,323 13.5%
17 $2,861 $572 $2,289 $599 $0.00 $28,184 14.2%
18 $3,090 $618 $2,472 $646 $0.00 $31,274 14.9%
19 $3,337 $667 $2,669 $698 $0.00 $34,611 15.5%
20 $3,604 $721 $2,883 $754 $0.00 $38,215 16.0%

IRS Partner’s Basis Worksheet — Key Years

Partner’s Instructions for Schedule K-1 (Form 1065), Worksheet for Adjusting the Basis of a Partner’s Interest in the Partnership, Lines 1–14.

Year 1 — IRS Partner’s Basis Worksheet

Line 1: Beginning Basis $10,000 IRC §705(a) — $10,000
Line 2: Capital Contributions $0.00 IRC §722 — $0
Line 3: Increased Liabilities $0.00 IRC §752(a) — $0 (no liability increase)
Line 4: Income and Gain Items $167 IRC §705(a)(1) — $0.33/unit × 500 units = $167
Line 7: Subtotal $10,167 IRC §705(a) — $10,000 + $0 + $0 + $167 = $10,167
Line 8: Distributions $835 IRC §731 — $1.67/unit × 500 units = $835
Line 9: Decreased Liabilities $0.00 IRC §752(b) — $0 (no liability decrease)
Line 10: Basis Before Losses $9,332 IRC §731(a)(1) — $10,167 - $835 - $0 = $9,332
Line 11: Loss and Deduction Items $0.00 IRC §704(d) — $0
Line 14: Ending Basis $9,332 IRC §705(a) — $9,332 - $0 = $9,332

Year 5 — IRS Partner’s Basis Worksheet

Line 1: Beginning Basis $6,991 IRC §705(a) — $6,991
Line 2: Capital Contributions $0.00 IRC §722 — $0
Line 3: Increased Liabilities $0.00 IRC §752(a) — $0 (no liability increase)
Line 4: Income and Gain Items $227 IRC §705(a)(1) — $0.45/unit × 500 units = $227.20
Line 7: Subtotal $7,218 IRC §705(a) — $6,991 + $0 + $0 + $227.20 = $7,218.20
Line 8: Distributions $1,136 IRC §731 — $2.27/unit × 500 units = $1,136.01
Line 9: Decreased Liabilities $0.00 IRC §752(b) — $0 (no liability decrease)
Line 10: Basis Before Losses $6,082 IRC §731(a)(1) — $7,218.20 - $1,136.01 - $0 = $6,082.19
Line 11: Loss and Deduction Items $0.00 IRC §704(d) — $0
Line 14: Ending Basis $6,082 IRC §705(a) — $6,082.19 - $0 = $6,082

Year 10 — IRS Partner’s Basis Worksheet

Line 1: Beginning Basis $1,659 IRC §705(a) — $1,659
Line 2: Capital Contributions $0.00 IRC §722 — $0
Line 3: Increased Liabilities $0.00 IRC §752(a) — $0 (no liability increase)
Line 4: Income and Gain Items $334 IRC §705(a)(1) — $0.67/unit × 500 units = $333.83
Line 7: Subtotal $1,993 IRC §705(a) — $1,659 + $0 + $0 + $333.83 = $1,992.83
Line 8: Distributions $1,669 IRC §731 — $3.34/unit × 500 units = $1,669.17
Line 9: Decreased Liabilities $0.00 IRC §752(b) — $0 (no liability decrease)
Line 10: Basis Before Losses $324 IRC §731(a)(1) — $1,992.83 - $1,669.17 - $0 = $323.66
Line 11: Loss and Deduction Items $0.00 IRC §704(d) — $0
Line 14: Ending Basis $324 IRC §705(a) — $323.66 - $0 = $324

Year 15 — IRS Partner’s Basis Worksheet

Line 1: Beginning Basis $0.00 IRC §705(a) — $0
Line 2: Capital Contributions $0.00 IRC §722 — $0
Line 3: Increased Liabilities $0.00 IRC §752(a) — $0 (no liability increase)
Line 4: Income and Gain Items $491 IRC §705(a)(1) — $0.98/unit × 500 units = $490.51
Line 7: Subtotal $491 IRC §705(a) — $0 + $0 + $0 + $490.51 = $490.51
Line 8: Distributions $2,453 IRC §731 — $4.91/unit × 500 units = $2,452.56
Line 9: Decreased Liabilities $0.00 IRC §752(b) — $0 (no liability decrease)
Line 10: Basis Before Losses $0.00 IRC §731(a)(1) — $490.51 - $2,452.56 - $0 = -$1,962.05 → $0 (§731 gain: $1,962.05)
Line 11: Loss and Deduction Items $0.00 IRC §704(d) — $0
Line 14: Ending Basis $0.00 IRC §705(a) — $0 - $0 = $0

Year 20 — IRS Partner’s Basis Worksheet

Line 1: Beginning Basis $0.00 IRC §705(a) — $0
Line 2: Capital Contributions $0.00 IRC §722 — $0
Line 3: Increased Liabilities $0.00 IRC §752(a) — $0 (no liability increase)
Line 4: Income and Gain Items $721 IRC §705(a)(1) — $1.44/unit × 500 units = $720.72
Line 7: Subtotal $721 IRC §705(a) — $0 + $0 + $0 + $720.72 = $720.72
Line 8: Distributions $3,604 IRC §731 — $7.21/unit × 500 units = $3,603.61
Line 9: Decreased Liabilities $0.00 IRC §752(b) — $0 (no liability decrease)
Line 10: Basis Before Losses $0.00 IRC §731(a)(1) — $720.72 - $3,603.61 - $0 = -$2,882.89 → $0 (§731 gain: $2,882.89)
Line 11: Loss and Deduction Items $0.00 IRC §704(d) — $0
Line 14: Ending Basis $0.00 IRC §705(a) — $0 - $0 = $0

Sensitivity Analysis

Scenario Growth Year 10 Basis Year 20 Basis Zero-Basis Year 20-Year Tax Eff. Rate
Conservative 7.0% $770 $0.00 Year 11 $5,283 15.4%
Base Case 8.0% $324 $0.00 Year 11 $6,113 16.0%
Aggressive 10.0% $0.00 $0.00 Year 10 $8,124 17.0%

Sell vs. Inherit in Year 20

If Sold in Year 20

Market Value: $19,898

Adjusted Basis: $0.00

Total Gain: $19,898

§751 Ordinary (est.): ~$20,000

Remaining LTCG: -$102

Tax on Sale: $5,876

Net investment income tax (3.8%, R-1411-RATE-THRESHOLD): a capital loss on the units offsets the §751 amount this year only up to the §1211(b) amount ($3,000, or $1,500 if married filing separately) (Reg. §1.1411-4(d)(2)); any part over that amount is a §1212(b) carryover, which this estimate does not model. The estimate treats the §751 amount as net investment income for a holder for whom the units were a passive activity in every year held (R-1411-NET-GAIN-CAPITAL-LOSS, condition 1); no source states this for a sale. This assumes no other capital gains or losses and no other net investment income; other items change the amount.

If the Units Pass at Death in Year 20

Market Value: $19,898

Successor’s basis (generally the value at that date, or the §2032 alternate value if elected; before the liability-share and IRD adjustments; projected): $19,898

Successor’s Tax on a Later Sale: not computed

If the units pass at death, the successor’s basis is generally the fair market value at that date (or at the alternate valuation date where the executor elects under §2032), increased by the successor’s share of partnership liabilities on that date and reduced to the extent the value is attributable to income in respect of a decedent; this sets the outside basis only. The partnership’s basis in its own property, from which the §751 amount on a later sale is figured, is adjusted for the successor only if a §754 election is in effect or the partnership has a substantial built-in loss immediately after the transfer (R-1014-PTP-STEP-UP). Whether any part of the §751 amount is income in respect of a decedent is not settled here. This tool does not compute the successor’s tax.

The tax on a sale by you in Year 20 is the “Tax on Sale” figure in the sell box. This is the tax this projection computes for a sale by you at the projected value. It does not measure any tax saved or avoided if the units pass at death, and it is not the successor’s tax, which this tool does not compute.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is my PAA basis after 10 years?

After 10 years of holding 500 PAA units, your IRS-adjusted basis drops from $10,000 to $324. This is calculated using the IRS Partner’s Basis Worksheet (IRC §705(a)), Lines 1–14, applying 8.0% annual distribution growth and ~80% return of capital.

When does PAA basis reach zero?

At base-case assumptions, PAA basis reaches zero in Year 11. After that, distributions trigger §731 capital gains — you owe tax on distributions even though your brokerage statement shows no change. This is sometimes called “phantom income.”

How much tax if I sell PAA after 20 years?

If you sell 500 PAA units after 20 years at an estimated market value of $19,898, total tax on sale is $5,876. This includes ~$20,000 in §751 ordinary income recapture (taxed as ordinary income) and -$102 in capital gain.

What if I sell PAA in Year 20, and what if the units pass at death?

A sale by you in Year 20 at the projected value carries $5,876 in tax in this projection. If the units pass at death instead, the successor’s basis is generally the fair market value at that date (or the §2032 alternate value if the executor elects), increased by the successor’s share of partnership liabilities on that date and reduced to the extent the value is attributable to income in respect of a decedent; here the projected value $19,898 before those adjustments, outside basis only; the partnership’s basis in its property, from which the §751 amount on a later sale is figured, is adjusted only with a §754 election or a substantial built-in loss immediately after the transfer (R-1014-PTP-STEP-UP). This page does not compute the successor’s tax, and no amount here is a tax saved or avoided at death.

What is PAA’s distribution yield after tax?

The nominal distribution yield is 8.3%. Due to the high return-of-capital percentage (~80%), most of the distribution is tax-deferred. The 20-year effective tax rate on cash received is 16.0%, making the after-tax yield approximately 7.0%.

Should I hold PAA in an IRA?

Holding MLPs in an IRA triggers Unrelated Business Taxable Income (UBTI) under IRC §512. If UBTI exceeds $1,000 in a tax year, the IRA must file Form 990-T and pay tax at trust rates. For PAA with 500 units generating ~$167 in annual taxable income, this threshold may or may not be reached depending on the year. Most MLP investors prefer taxable accounts to preserve the §1014 step-up benefit.

What is the successor’s basis if PAA units pass at death?

If the units pass at death, the successor’s basis is generally the fair market value at that date (or at the alternate valuation date where the executor elects under §2032), increased by the successor’s share of partnership liabilities on that date and reduced to the extent the value is attributable to income in respect of a decedent (§1014(a); R-1014-PTP-STEP-UP). In this projection that value is $19,898 before those adjustments. This sets the outside basis only: the partnership’s basis in its property, from which the §751 amount on a later sale is figured (this projection’s §751 amount for a sale by you in Year 20 is about $20,000), is adjusted only with a §754 election or a substantial built-in loss immediately after the transfer, and whether any part of that amount is income in respect of a decedent is not settled. This page does not compute the successor’s tax.

How complicated is PAA’s K-1?

PAA issues 1 K-1 form per year. The K-1 includes state allocation schedules for ~18 states, which may require additional state tax filings depending on your home state’s de minimis thresholds.

MLP Estate Planning

The full 5-part series covers trust types and family situations:

Related Tools & Guides

Methodology

Computed using the IRS Partner’s Basis Worksheet, Lines 1–14, from the Partner’s Instructions for Schedule K-1 (Form 1065). Every calculated value maps to a specific IRC section, K-1 box, and tax return form line.

Projection engine: 429 test cases passing, last verified 2026-11-05. Engine version 0.1.0.

Built by Lucas Andersen. Proprietary energy trader and direct MLP holder.

Partner’s Instructions for Schedule K-1 (Form 1065) — IRS Publication 541 (Partnerships)